The Ministry of Labor, through Circular 067 of 2022, ordered the processing of complaints for refusal to negotiate petitions by companies, making it clear that this will be a priority issue for the administration. Among other key points of the attached circular, it defined:
1. Complaints for refusal to negotiate They must have special and prompt attention by the Labor Inspectors and Territorial Directorates, once filed, must be convened IMMEDIATELY to the parties involved in the conflict, especially to the party that refuses to negotiate, to state the reasons why it refrains from initiating negotiations.
2. The Ministry clarifies that the reasons for refusing to negotiate are exceptional and that it will only accept those listed below:
“A. The collective bargaining agreement was not denounced within the 60 days immediately preceding the expiration of its term in accordance with articles 478 and 479 of the Substantive Labor Code or as provided for in the text of the agreement.
B. The petition was not submitted within two months of its adoption in accordance with Article 16 of Law 11 of 1984, which replaced Article 376 of the Substantive Labor Code.
C. The petition was not approved in accordance with the mechanisms prescribed in the statutes for making the respective decision.”
3. If the employer raises any other reason for refusing to negotiate, the Labor Inspector, with respect to due process, must initiate disciplinary proceedings. The Ministry even clarifies that if he imposes a sanction, he will forward copies to the Attorney General's Office, as an act that violates the right to union association based on the provisions of Article 200 of the Penal Code.
The circular also states that the Ministry will not accept as justification for not negotiating the claim of lack of legitimacy of the organization or illegal or abusive actions on its part. Of course, this can be discussed before the courts.
In fact, the Circular is emphatic in indicating that in cases of unjustified refusal, what is appropriate is a sanction and not merely a requirement to negotiate, making clear the restrictive nature of this guideline.
4. Furthermore, the Ministry states that if negotiations begin, there would be room to file the complaint. However, it seems that in cases where it does not accept any argument for the delay in the start of negotiations, there would be a risk of sanctions.
Finally, this circular is yet another example of the new position of the Ministry of Labor, more inquisitive and restrictive with companies, requiring that as a company we carry out internal reviews and action plans to mitigate risks.