The Labor Cassation Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, in a recent ruling SL 2235-2023, reiterated that when a collective labor conflict ends abnormally, by subtraction of subject matter, the circumstantial privilege also ends.
In fact, according to Article 25 of Decree 2351 of 1965, workers who submit a list of demands to the company cannot be dismissed without just cause, which is known as circumstantial privilege. Although the norm is not express in determining until when this protection extends, the jurisprudence of the Labor Chamber has established that it lasts as long as the collective conflict, whether it ends normally or abnormally.
The conflict normally ends with the signing of the collective bargaining agreement or when an arbitration award is issued that puts an end to the conflict. Normally, when the union shows a lack of interest in concluding it and, when it is not diligent in complying with the stages established for collective bargaining or, the subsequent stages of conflict resolution established by law if no agreement is reached.
It should be specified that the abnormal termination is not only defined by the prolongation of the conflict in time, since there may be justifying circumstances for such delay. More than that, it is necessary to determine the responsibility of the party in the fulfillment of its obligations or requirements for the stages of the conflict to follow their legal, ordinary and reasonable course.
Since this is not an easy matter to elucidate, but requires a technical and specialized analysis, we at Chapman Wilches are at your disposal if you have any particular concerns regarding your specific case.
Source: Supreme Court of Justice. Labor Cassation Chamber. Ruling SL2235-2023.